‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’ Is a Faint Echo of the Series’ Highs

Rather than expanding the world of Panem, the latest prequel feels like an excuse to have younger actors play familiar characters.

Share
Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping | Image via Lionsgate

I found 2023’s The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes to be a welcome surprise. Although it was a prequel, the only returning character was Coriolanus Snow, and the film played as a thoughtful drama about a man who sheds his remaining virtue due to his ambition and resentment. It also showed a young Panem, one where the arena is little more than a concrete bunker, and the war that created the games is still fresh in everyone’s minds. Unfortunately, the new prequel, Sunrise on the Reaping, does what too many prequels are content to accomplish these days: coloring inside established lines. Rather than add fresh revelations, the film functions more as an exercise in how younger actors would take on supporting characters from the original quartet of movies. Some do it better than others, but it’s all more of a curiosity than a reason to play the games again.

Set 24 years before the first movie, the story follows young Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada), a pleasant enough young man whose birthday falls on the same day as the reaping every year. This year, while trying to protect his girlfriend Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak), he ends up becoming one of District 12’s tributes. Taken to the Capitol to compete in the Second Quarter Quell, he meets people like Beetee Latier (Kelvin Harrison Jr.) and insider Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons), who are looking to take down the games by breaking the arena. However, the watchful eye of President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) makes rebellion difficult, and as we know, the games will continue until the arrival of Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence).

The film’s biggest problem is that there’s not much to Haymitch. His function in the first book, aside from being Katniss’ mentor, is to show that even if you win the games, you still lose. He’s a cynical, traumatized loner, showing that the Capitol has nothing to offer even to those who manage to survive. Expanding his story casts him as an everyman, and whether it’s a function of the script or Zada’s performance, there’s little to latch onto beyond the repetition of his plot beats, which typically involve him saying to someone, “I’ll protect you,” and then, because this is The Hunger Games, that person dies, and he feels guilty. There’s an inkling here of how trying to craft your own story within a vast media machine becomes an exercise in futility, but even here, Haymitch’s choices feel reactive rather than deeds of a man with an interior life.

Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping | Image via Murray Close/Lionsgate

Without a compelling lead character as we had with Songbirds & Snakes, the rest of the piece serves as little more than a way to see how a crop of younger acclaimed performers would take on familiar roles. Some do an outstanding job, like Plemons finding his own take on Heavensbee that feels aligned with what Philip Seymour Hoffman did, yet not an imitation. Harrison’s choice is to imitate Jeffrey Wright with such precision you would think they were the same guy. Elle Fanning takes a similar tack with playing a young Effie Trinket, adopting the cheerful mannerisms of Elizabeth Banks.

And then there is Kieran Culkin as young Caesar Flickerman, who gives a performance so bad it makes you wonder if we’ve misjudged his ability this whole time. He’s under no obligation to try and copy Stanley Tucci, but what reeks here is his total indifference to doing anything other than what we’ve seen him do for years now, which is play a charismatic asshole. This is Succession’s Roman Roy in different clothes, and it’s disappointing to see his fellow actors at least try to work within a preestablished character while he does the same old song and dance. Is Caesar a callous jerk? Yes, but in a way that’s more about the cold vapidity of a morning talk show host rather than firing off mean little jokes. Culkin has won an Emmy and Oscar for playing this particular kind of guy, but I now seriously doubt he can do anything else.

But wherever they land, they’re all forcing us to draw comparisons to actors who had the benefit of playing a character for 3-4 movies, and it wears away at any kind of distinction Sunrise might have beyond the 70s sheen director Francis Lawrence provides to this era of the dystopia. It’s telling that the most memorable performances are Effie’s predecessor, Drusilla Sickle (Glenn Close), a hardhearted woman sporting full Mar-a-Lago face, and Haymitch’s fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace), who feels a bit like a prelude to Katniss, but with a distinctive spark. They’re both new characters, and they make the world feel bigger rather than shrinking it to the familiar.

The lack of freshness is what sinks the new movie because it feels like Lawrence and his writers have little more to add here. The script hints at what it means to have a nascent rebellion, but that would require Haymitch to have a stronger character (it also doesn’t help that we recently saw this concept executed perfectly in Andor). Moreover, previous Hunger Games movies thrive on the intersection between authoritarianism and the media, and that’s largely absent here despite the increased role of Heavensbee. What we’re really getting here is the comfort of fan service, and if there was one thing previous Hunger Games movies succeeded at, it was making the audience uncomfortable with the amount of fascist carnage they were willing to depict. Where previous movies sought to unsettle, Sunrise on the Reaping is here ultimately to reassure, and that’s a losing formula for this series.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens November 20.